New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs Predictions
Saturday, October 17, 2026 at 7:00pm EST
Maple Leafs
Professional Picks On This Game
No professional picks are available for this matchup.
Islanders vs. Maple Leafs Prediction: Toronto Favored, but -135 Is a Pass
Analysis updated October 17, 2026 at 8:55 AM CDT
The Maple Leafs are the likelier winner, but the Islanders’ goaltending and defensive results make Toronto too expensive at -135.
New York’s defense makes Toronto’s price hard to back
Toronto is a -135 home favorite, with New York at +114. The New York Islanders / NHL.com preview reports that the Islanders have allowed 16 non-shootout goals through seven games and three or fewer goals in five of them. Their 2.29 goals-against average ranked second in the NHL, making Toronto’s price unattractive despite its home-ice advantage.
Ilya Sorokin and Semyon Varlamov each entered with a goals-against average below 2.00. New York hadn’t confirmed its starting goalie or final lineup, however, so the Islanders’ strong early numbers don’t provide enough certainty to support a wager on either side.
Matthews and special teams favor Toronto
Auston Matthews entered with six goals, seven assists and a six-game point streak. Toronto also ranked first on the penalty kill at 96.2% and fifth on the power play at 29.6%, according to New York Islanders / NHL.com. Those advantages make the Maple Leafs the more likely winner.
The concern is Toronto’s defense. The Maple Leafs had allowed at least three goals in seven of eight games and 30.5 shots per game, fourth most in the NHL. They also surrendered a 4-2 third-period lead in Thursday’s 5-4 overtime loss to Buffalo. That record of allowing chances is difficult to accept at -135 against a team that has defended well.
Prediction
Toronto is the low-confidence winner because Matthews and its special teams can decide a close game. The moneyline is still a pass, and the unconfirmed goaltenders and lineups leave too much uncertainty to support a score prediction.