Colgate
Raiders
3-1
Spread
+2.5
NCAAF Predictions
Colgate Raiders vs Villanova Wildcats Predictions
Saturday, September 26, 2026 at 2:30pm EST at Villanova Stadium, Philadelphia, PA
@
Villanova
Wildcats
2-2
Spread
-2.5
50%
50%
Spread
Colgate Raiders +2.5
Villanova Wildcats -2.5
Moneyline
Colgate Raiders +114
Villanova Wildcats -142
Total
Over 44.5 (-111)
Under 44.5 (-111)
Who wins this game?
Professional Picks
1 available
Professional Picks On This Game
Garrett Perry
Total pick
Colgate vs. Villanova Prediction: Wildcats Favored in Close Patriot League Matchup
Analysis updated September 26, 2026 at 7:46 AM CDT
Villanova’s recent comeback and success in this series point to the Wildcats as the likely winner. The available evidence doesn’t justify laying -142 or 2.5 points.
Villanova’s case starts with late-game execution
Villanova University Athletics reports that the Wildcats rallied past LIU 20-16 last week. Pat McQuaide completed 19 of 27 passes for 223 yards and led an 85-yard winning drive, finishing it with a touchdown pass to Ja'briel Mace with 1:08 remaining. That performance supports Villanova’s status as the -142 home favorite in a game priced for a narrow margin.
Mace also rushed for 97 yards and a touchdown against LIU, while Brandon Binkowski has 18 catches for 259 yards through four games. Villanova has won eight of its past nine meetings with Colgate, including a 24-17 home victory in 2025. Those results give the Wildcats a reasonable path to another close win, but they don’t make the -2.5 spread a bargain.
Why the wager is a pass
Colgate enters 3-1 overall and 2-0 in Patriot League play, compared with Villanova’s 2-2 overall record and 1-1 league mark. The Raiders’ better start matters when the market asks bettors to lay points with Villanova, yet no current Colgate statistics, confirmed starters or injury information are available to show whether the Raiders match up well here.
The 50-50 betting split is a default reading rather than evidence of public preference, and there is no opening price or line movement to evaluate. Villanova is the more supportable winner based on its recent offensive production and series history, but the missing Colgate information leaves the moneyline, spread and 44.5-point total without a sound betting case. Pass.
Pick
Villanova Wildcats
Confidence
low
Betting lean
Pass