NCAAF Predictions

New Mexico Highlands Cowboys vs Western New Mexico Mustangs Predictions

Thursday, September 3, 2026 at 8:00pm EST

New Mexico Highlands

Cowboys

Spread
@
Western New Mexico

Mustangs

Spread
50% 50%
Spread New Mexico Highlands Cowboys Western New Mexico Mustangs
Moneyline New Mexico Highlands Cowboys Western New Mexico Mustangs
Total None
Professional Picks

Professional Picks On This Game

0 listed

No professional picks are available for this matchup.

Staff Preview

New Mexico Highlands vs. Western New Mexico Prediction: Mustangs Hold the Rushing Edge

Analysis updated September 3, 2026 at 4:11 PM CDT

Western New Mexico's deep rushing attack gives the Mustangs a narrow edge in Silver City. With no moneyline, spread or total posted at SPF, however, the betting call is a pass.

Matchup outlook

The La Batalla Bowl brings together two 1-0 teams coming off high-scoring openers. New Mexico Highlands edged Eastern New Mexico 35-34, while Western New Mexico beat Adams State 62-45.

Western New Mexico ran for 496 yards on 48 attempts against Adams State. New Mexico Highlands produced 460 total yards, including 236 on the ground. One game is not enough to establish a reliable trend, but both offenses have already shown they can turn this matchup into a shootout.

Western New Mexico's rushing depth stands out

The Mustangs overwhelmed Adams State with several runners. Devon Nofoa-Masoe rushed for 238 yards and two touchdowns. Joshua Gaines scored four rushing touchdowns and another as a receiver, while quarterback Jase Ashley ran for 146 yards and a score.

Ashley completed 7 of 18 passes for 92 yards, making early-down success important against a defense that can crowd the line. Western New Mexico also committed no turnovers and forced three. Another plus-three turnover margin would put New Mexico Highlands in a difficult spot.

The Cowboys have an answer on offense

New Mexico Highlands can counter with quarterback Kadyn Parr, who completed 14 of 20 passes for 224 yards and three touchdowns against Eastern New Mexico. He also rushed for 63 yards and a score. Ashton Bradford added 109 yards and a touchdown on 13 carries, plus 66 yards and another score on two receptions.

The Cowboys averaged 7.0 yards per play, recorded 24 first downs and held the ball for 37:26. Sustaining long drives would limit the Mustangs' rushing opportunities and keep their offense off the field.

The defensive evidence is less encouraging. New Mexico Highlands won by one point despite its efficient offense, and Western New Mexico allowed 45 points. Neither opener suggests that either defense can take control for an extended stretch.

Prediction and betting outlook

Western New Mexico's rushing performance must hold up against a different opponent. New Mexico Highlands will need Parr's efficiency and Bradford's versatility to maintain its balance. With both offenses moving the ball and finishing drives in Week 0, a turnover or stalled possession could decide the game.

The Silver City evening forecast calls for partly cloudy skies, a slight chance of showers or thunderstorms, and winds of 10 to 15 mph. The conditions do not clearly favor either team, though wind or a passing shower could place more emphasis on the running games.

Western New Mexico is the more likely winner. Its rushing production came from several dangerous ball carriers, and its three takeaways created extra possessions in the opener. Confidence is only medium because each team has played once and the research includes no verified player-availability report.

That does not make Western New Mexico worth betting at an unknown price. SPF has posted no moneyline, spread or total, so there is no number against which to judge the Mustangs' matchup risk. There is also no supported case for backing New Mexico Highlands or playing the total without a line. The prediction is Western New Mexico 45, New Mexico Highlands 41. The betting lean is a pass.

Pick Western New Mexico Mustangs
Projected score Western New Mexico 45, New Mexico Highlands 41
Confidence medium
Betting lean Pass
Odds and availability can change. Confirm current markets before placing a wager.