St. Louis Blues vs Pittsburgh Penguins Predictions
Thursday, November 19, 2026 at 7:00pm EST at PPG Paints Arena, Pittsburgh, PA
Penguins
8-2-1Who wins this game?
Professional Picks On This Game
No professional picks are available for this matchup.
Blues vs. Penguins Prediction: Home History Favors Pittsburgh, but Pass at -112
Analysis updated November 19, 2026 at 7:15 AM CST
The Penguins have controlled this matchup at home, but their recent form and the unsettled goalie matchup limit the case for betting them.
Pittsburgh’s home record is the strongest angle
Pittsburgh Penguins / NHL.com reports that the Penguins have won six consecutive home games against St. Louis dating to December 2019. Pittsburgh is also 8-2-1 in the past 11 meetings overall. That history gives the Penguins a slight edge in the winner prediction, but SPF’s -112 moneyline already makes this close to a pick’em.
Recent results offer a counterpoint. Probetrics, a game and betting data site, lists St. Louis at 3-2-0 over its past five games and Pittsburgh at 2-3-0. The Penguins had four days off compared with one for the Blues, which may help Pittsburgh, but it isn’t enough to justify a wager without knowing the starting goalies.
Unconfirmed goalies make the price hard to trust
Probetrics identifies Jordan Binnington and Sergei Murashov as each team’s goalie from its previous game, but neither is confirmed to start. That uncertainty affects both the moneyline and SPF’s 6.5-goal total, where the Under costs -122.
Pittsburgh is the more likely winner because of its sustained success in this matchup at home. Still, laying -112 with an unconfirmed starter and weaker five-game form is a thin proposition. Pittsburgh -1.5 requires a multi-goal win even though the moneyline prices the teams almost evenly, so the side and puck line are both passes.