MLB Predictions

New York Yankees vs New York Mets

Sunday, May 17, 2026 at 1:40pm EST

Away

New York Yankees

Spread -1.5

Home

Spread +1.5

59%

41%

Spread New York Yankees -1.5 New York Mets +1.5

Moneyline New York Yankees +105 New York Mets -126

Total Over 9 (-104) Under 9 (-116)

Professional Picks

10 listed

Owen Timmons Money pick

In Progress

Blake Mitchum Money pick

In Progress

Joe Napoli Money pick

In Progress

Kevin McHughe Money pick

In Progress

Jonah Black Money pick

In Progress

Dave Vernin Money pick

In Progress

Simon Says Money pick

In Progress

Simon Says Total pick

In Progress

Allen Barclay Spread pick

In Progress

Garrett Perry Money pick

In Progress

Previous Matchups

2/22 3/8 5/15 5/16 5/17