Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Predictions
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 7:00pm EST at UBS Arena, Elmont, NY
Islanders
2-0-1Who wins this game?
Professional Picks On This Game
No professional picks are available for this matchup.
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders Prediction: New York Has the Edge, but Pass at -142
Analysis updated November 17, 2026 at 7:31 AM CST
The Islanders have the stronger recent results and Columbus is 1-5-0 on the road, but unconfirmed starting goalies make New York's -142 moneyline difficult to justify.
Islanders bring the better form
The New York Islanders / NHL.com game preview lists New York at 9-6-4 after a 2-0-1 California trip that included wins of 5-2 over Los Angeles and 6-2 over Anaheim. Columbus entered at 7-11-0 following four consecutive losses, and its 1-5-0 road record strengthens the case for New York as the likely winner.
Simon Holmstrom had five goals and three assists over his previous four games, while Matthew Schaefer led the Islanders with 21 points in 19 games. Columbus has a dangerous scorer of its own in Kent Johnson, who recorded 13 points over his previous 10 games, so New York's recent form doesn't make the -142 moneyline an automatic bet.
Unconfirmed goalies limit the betting case
Neither starting goalie was confirmed. Columbus' options had produced sharply different results: Cam Talbot carried a 2.51 goals-against average and .909 save percentage, compared with Jet Greaves' 3.42 and .875 marks. That uncertainty affects both the moneyline and the 5.5 total.
New York is the likely winner, but -142 is too expensive without confirmed starters. The over costs -118 and the under -102, and the goalie uncertainty leaves no clear reason to take either side. Pass.